As I mentioned in earlier posts we are using the Hodder AQA KS3 Science Book 2 this year for my daughter’s Science. And that means both a Student Book and Practice Book (there are two practice books to chose from so this post is about the two practice books). But before we go further, so there is no confusion – the Student Book – is the book with the explanations in it and a few questions. The Practice Books do not contain explanations, they are books filled with questions on the topics that are covered in the Student Book (all answers are Free to download from the Hodder website).
The two Practice Books are called – Know and Apply and Extend. This can be a bit confusing because the questions inside each practice book are split up into sections called Know, Apply and Extend (I find this a bit confusing). I was given the Extend practice book a few months ago (to use in a different post) but I was curious to see how the questions in the two Practice Books would differ and I was wanting to figure out if it would help to buy both practice books, so I bought the Know and Apply Practice book myself so I could compare. (Just to clarify I am the type of home educator who likes to have lots of questions, I am of the opinion that it is better to lots of questions and you choose which ones to work through.)
Each topic is broken down into 3 sets of questions – Know, Apply and Extend. The first practice book (Now and Apply) does NOT have any extend questions in it whereas the Extend practice book has the Know questions, the Apply questions and the Extend questions.
This photo shows some of the Forces questions in the Know and Apply Practice Book.
This photo show some of the Forces questions in the Extend Practice Book. You can see the Know and Apply sections are the same but they have also included an Extend set of questions.
Also in the student book at the end of each Topic there are pages called Extend. The Now and Apply practice book does not cover any of this content. But the Extend practice book has questions for all of the Extend pages that are in the Student book. (In the photo below – Drag and Levers where included under an Extend section in the Student Book so only the Extend Practice Book had questions on Drag and Levers. There were NO questions on Drag and Levers in the Know and Apply Practice Book.)
So straight away the Extend book has a MORE questions in it that the Know And Apply Book.
Now because both practice books contain questions for the Know and Apply sections you might be wondering are the questions under Know and Apply sections always the same in both practice books? That is a tough one, in a lot of the sections the questions under the Know and Apply sections are identical in the two books. But in some sections they have included extra questions in the Know and Apply Workbook. The first photo shows some Know questions from the Know and Apply Practice Book dealing with Stress, in this case they have included extra questions.
And the same Know section in the Extend Practice Book.
And in a few cases they have included a whole page or so at the beginning of the topic in the Know and Apply workbook which is NOT in the Extend practice book.
We have worked through the Physics in both books and although they did include a Few questions in the Know and Apply book that were not in the Extend book for the most part the Extend book had by far the larger range of questions and it really did include most of the questions that were in the Know and Apply practice book. We have only just started using this range and I will probably have a more informed opinion at the end of the year once we have worked through all the sections but currently my thinking is go for the Extend practice book (don’t buy both) and rather just leave out questions that you think may be too hard or why not just talk through the harder questions with the kids and do them together.
You can buy these directly from Hodder Education or you can buy them from Amazon –
Admin – I do include Affiliate links. If you follow an affiliate link and go on to purchase that product, I will be paid a very small commission, however your cost will remain the same. I only include affiliate links for products that we use.